Government Denies Internet Outages Losses, Promises Better Connectivity

Information Minister Attaullah Tarar recently asserted that Pakistan’s internet services are “much better and cheaper” compared to several other countries while dismissing claims that the country faced massive financial losses due to internet outages in 2024. His remarks were made during the opening ceremony of the Media Cricket League 2025, where he also promised further improvements in the coming days.

The Controversial Report

A report from Top10VPN.com, an independent VPN reviewer, claimed that Pakistan led the world in financial losses from internet outages and social media shutdowns in 2024. The report estimated the losses to be a staggering $1.62 billion. It highlighted frequent disruptions in internet services, which users experienced as slow speeds, difficulties downloading media on WhatsApp, and intermittent connectivity.

However, Tarar refuted the claims, suggesting they lacked substantial evidence. “This was calculated by a VPN forum, but I believe the internet has gotten better. You won’t find cheaper internet than we have here,” he remarked, citing advertisements offering unlimited data packages by telecom companies and local internet service providers. He acknowledged some glitches in the past but dismissed concerns, calling them politically motivated discussions without proof.

Government’s Perspective on Internet Issues

Digital analysts had previously suggested that the government was testing a “firewall” system to monitor platforms and restrict content. While the government denied throttling internet services, it did confirm working on a “web management system” aimed at enhancing cybersecurity. This created the perception that the government tied intermittent internet issues to broader strategies for digital regulation.

Despite these allegations, Information Minister Tarar expressed confidence in the progress made. “The internet has improved, and in the future, we aim to make it even better,” he stated.

A Broader Look at IT Sector Growth

IT Minister Shaza Fatima Khawaja also weighed in on the matter, presenting data to counter claims of persistent internet interruptions. She pointed out a 33% growth in Pakistan’s IT exports over five months, which she argued would not have been possible if internet outages were a recurrent issue.

Khawaja further highlighted a 25% increase in internet users between 2023 and 2024, crediting the IT ministry’s “tedious and committed efforts” for improving connectivity. This growth, she said, reflected significant strides made in providing affordable and reliable internet services across the country.

Moving Forward

While concerns about internet stability and security remain, government officials appear optimistic about the future. Both ministers emphasized ongoing upgrades and efforts to address past shortcomings, dismissing the critical report as an exaggeration. The discourse around internet affordability and accessibility in Pakistan continues to evolve, but for now, the government remains focused on expanding connectivity and improving digital infrastructure.

Our Thoughts

The debate on Pakistan’s internet performance underlines the importance of transparency and evidence-based discussions. While the government paints an optimistic picture, independent evaluations like those from Top10VPN.com serve as a reminder of the challenges that remain. Moving forward, addressing these gaps will be essential for Pakistan’s digital transformation.

See Also: How Starlink Could Revolutionize Internet Access Across Pakistan