IT Minister Justifies Online Surveillance & Denies Ongoing Internet Issues

The recent IT committee meeting witnessed intense discussions on internet outages, online surveillance, and its impact on industries in Pakistan. Minister of State for IT & Telecom, Shaza Fatima Khawaja, defended the government’s stance, asserting that internet disruptions were temporary and had been resolved.

“Our entire security paradigm is changing,” stated Shaza Fatima, emphasizing the rising threat of terrorism. She mentioned the loss of more than 100 soldiers in the past month and argued for the necessity of targeted surveillance. “I agree that there should not be unnecessary surveillance on citizens. However, where necessary, we have to conduct surveillance,” she said.

Moreover, Shaza dismissed concerns over ongoing internet issues, citing a $1.5 billion export figure from the previous month. “If the internet is down, where is this revenue coming from?” she asked. The minister further stated that the Chairman of PASHA confirmed no industry is currently facing internet-related problems. She also mentioned ongoing discussions with Starlink about introducing satellite internet in Pakistan.

Another committee member, Romina Khurshid Alam also supported the need for surveillance. Monitoring happens worldwide. “If something is happening against the state, it should be monitored. Even cartoons are monitored in foreign countries. We come to standing committees to strengthen the country,” she said.

However, Shaza’s remarks brought criticism from key government ally, Pakistan People’s Party (PPP) leader Sharmila Farooqi, who expressed frustration over the minister’s remarks. “I am very disappointed. Four meetings have been held, and no solution has been reached,” said Sharmila. She claimed that the e-commerce sector, including her husband’s company, faced significant losses due to internet shutdowns. “Either we are lying, or the government is lying,” she added.

Our Opinion

While the minister’s emphasis on national security and technological advancements is admirable, concerns raised by stakeholders, highlight a gap between policy implementation and ground realities. Internet shutdowns have undeniable economic repercussions, especially for the e-commerce sector. Transparency, proactive communication, and stakeholder engagement are crucial to addressing these challenges and ensuring a balanced approach that safeguards both national security and economic growth.

Also read:

Opposition & Govt Allies Criticize Internet Outages in IT Committee Meeting