Opposition to AI Regulation in Pakistan: A Balanced Approach or a Missed Opportunity?

The Ministry of Information Technology and Telecommunication (MoITT) has opposed prematurely Artificial Intelligence (AI) regulation in Pakistan. According to official sources, the ministry believes it is too early to introduce a regulatory body for this evolving technology, as the country’s AI ecosystem is still in its nascent stages.

The Proposed Bill of AI Regulation in Pakistan

The Senate Secretariat recently shared a draft bill titled the “Regulation of Artificial Intelligence Act 2024”, which aims to establish provisions for regulating AI and related technologies. The Ministry of IT and Telecom, however, has expressed reservations about such regulation, citing the global trend of prioritizing AI policy and ecosystem development over-regulation. MoITT argues that AI’s potential for growth and innovation outweighs the immediate need for regulatory oversight, though it acknowledges the risks associated with the technology.

Global and Local Context

Globally, more than 50 countries have implemented national-level AI strategies, while fewer than 10 have introduced specific legislation to regulate AI. This reflects a deliberate choice to foster AI ecosystems before imposing legal constraints. Countries with advanced AI industries prioritize data governance, availability, and protection as foundational pillars. These steps ensure a robust framework to support AI innovation before addressing regulation.

In Pakistan, the focus on ecosystem development is evident. The Ministry of Planning, Development, and Special Initiatives (MOPDSI) leads the national AI initiative, supported by an inclusive task force comprising stakeholders from the public sector, academia, and industry. Similarly, MoITT has formed an AI Committee tasked with finalizing a National AI Policy. This policy aims to guide the development of a sustainable AI ecosystem in alignment with the National AI Plan being devised by MOPDSI.

Challenges to Address

For Pakistan, fundamental issues such as data governance, availability, and protection need urgent attention. Without these cornerstones, any attempt to regulate AI might stifle innovation and hinder technological progress. Both federal and provincial governments are being included in the policy-making process to ensure a comprehensive approach that addresses these foundational needs.

Is This a Good Step?

The ministry’s stance on prioritizing ecosystem building over-regulation is aligned with international best practices, which emphasize creating an enabling environment for innovation. However, the risks associated with AI—such as ethical concerns, misuse, and data privacy issues—demand proactive measures. A complete absence of oversight could leave room for these challenges to escalate, potentially harming public trust in AI systems.

Navigating the Future of AI in Pakistan

While the ministry’s focus on ecosystem development is commendable, a hybrid approach might serve Pakistan better. Developing a flexible regulatory framework alongside the AI ecosystem can address immediate risks without stifling innovation. This could involve setting guidelines for ethical AI use, encouraging responsible AI development, and gradually introducing regulations as the ecosystem matures.

AI offers immense opportunities, from enhancing economic productivity to revolutionizing healthcare and education. However, the government must ensure that its approach balances fostering innovation with safeguarding public interest. By adopting a phased and inclusive strategy, Pakistan can position itself as a leader in ethical and sustainable AI development.

See Also: MoiTT Sets High IT Export Remittance Targets – Realistic or Overambitious?